The Discerning Texan

All that is necessary for evil to triumph, is for good men to do nothing.
-- Edmund Burke
Thursday, June 07, 2007

Colorado Sheriff: Gun Free Zone at VT might have cost lives

When law enforcement officials are joining the chorus of citizens--who believe that so called "Gun Free Zones" are an open invitation to killers and predators--the maybe, just maybe it is time for us to get over the utopian PC academics and the anti-Second Amendment politicians and allow people who are licensed to do so to protect themselves.

So how many more Virginia Techs have to happen before our "leaders" finally get off the schneid? (h/t Instapundit)

Labels: , ,

DiscerningTexan, 6/07/2007 07:46:00 PM | Permalink | |
Wednesday, May 16, 2007

South Carolina Legislators want MORE Guns on Campus

I've always liked South Carolina; whenever I have visited it always seemed like a place where they "get it". I even have a "Palmetto Cap" which I wear quite frequently, and tonight I wear it proudly.

It would have been nice if something like this had been in place at Virginia Tech.

In case you are not up to date on the statistics of violent crime when carry laws are vs. are not present, go no further than John R. Lott, Jr.'s fine book More Guns, Less Crime. The numbers are very telling.

Labels: , ,

DiscerningTexan, 5/16/2007 06:23:00 PM | Permalink | |
Wednesday, May 02, 2007

Guaranteed Body Count: Courtesy of the PC Left


Cartoon by Scott Stantis (click to enlarge)

Labels: , ,

DiscerningTexan, 5/02/2007 11:46:00 PM | Permalink | |
Tuesday, May 01, 2007

Three Years on (post-Carry law) no gunbattles yet at U. of Utah

Dr. Helen found a real gem this week. Go figure that there has been no "Bowling for Colombine II" at the University of Utah...

Let's face it, if the Virginia Carry Bill had not been submarined by Democrats and Academic Lefties, there would likely be many fewer dead kids being mourned at Virginia Tech. I don't see how anyone could argue otherwise.

For someone like Cho to get all of the publicity he was seeking, he needed a place where he could easily rack up a big body count--a "Gun Free" zone provided the perfect opportunity. If he did not have the "assurance" that most people in the building he entered would not be armed (for fear of being expelled from the University), he might not have so eagerly entered that situation. And--secondarily--even if he had still gone in, fewer lives may have been taken had some student in one of those classrooms had a weapon to defend his/her self.

So it begs the question: why are we offering the typical deranged publicity-seeking psycho so many "target rich" opportunities by creating all these "gun free" zones in Right-to-Carry states? I can understand not allowing weapons in bars, but I'm having a bit of a problem understanding why a responsible armed teacher--even in grade schools--cannot have the means to protect innocent children from predators.

The answer is not to ban guns on campus. The answer is to allow citizens (in this case, students and faculty) who have proven themselves to be responsible adults (after loopholes are closed) to have the means to protect themselves and society from those who do not belong in it. Only then in my view will mass murders like the Virginia Tech tragedy subside in this country. It looks like the folks in Salt Lake City have figured that out.

I think it is time we took a hard look at this, before more Virginia Techs or another Beslan occurs here.

UPDATE: Glenn (and Gov. Perry) agrees.

Labels: , ,

DiscerningTexan, 5/01/2007 10:56:00 AM | Permalink | |
Wednesday, April 18, 2007

Is NBC Hiding Something on those Cho Videos?

Is there something on those Cho videos that the Politically Correct thought police at NBC doesn't want us to see? Is America incapable of "handling it" after 3 straight days of 24x7 "healing"?

They could certainly put questions like these to bed if they would only cough up the entire set of videotape and other documents that this sicko sent to NBC between shootings. Dave Winer (via Glenn Reynolds ) weighs in--I've condensed his format for space considerations:

NBC should release all of the videos in Quicktime form as downloads. It's wrong to withhold them. They're sifting through them and deciding what to release and what not to release. It's 2007, and it's a decentralized world. We should all get a chance to see what's on those videos. GIven enough time the focus will go on their process, much better to just let it all out now, with no editorial judgement. If you have contacts in the blogging world or MSM that could influence NBC's decision, please pass this on.
So let me get this straight--these networks can show us a repeated loop footage of Islamist snipers murdering our troops in Iraq (because we have a "need to know"), but when the whole country wants to know detail about this psychopath who perpetrated the worst campus massacre in US history, NBC decides we can't handle the truth? The irony of this is--if you haven't been on a remote island for the last 2 weeks--the most pressing problem with NBC is... Don Imus?

What am I missing here? Is this my beautiful home? Is this my beautiful wife? (Why can't is just be the same as it ever was?)

Labels: , , ,

DiscerningTexan, 4/18/2007 08:58:00 PM | Permalink | |

Steyn shines his penetrating light on "the Culture of Passivity"

Mark Steyn, the most prolific--and quite possibly the best--columnist in the English language, seems to be on the same wavelength as I regarding the critical illness of a culture which could create students that apparently stood by passively without fighting back as their classmates (and themselves) were executed one by one... (emphases are mine):
Point one: They’re not “children.” The students at Virginia Tech were grown women and — if you’ll forgive the expression — men. They would be regarded as adults by any other society in the history of our planet. Granted, we live in a selectively infantilized culture where twentysomethings are “children” if they’re serving in the Third Infantry Division in Ramadi but grown-ups making rational choices if they drop to the broadloom in President Clinton’s Oval Office. Nonetheless, it’s deeply damaging to portray fit fully formed adults as children who need to be protected. We should be raising them to understand that there will be moments in life when you need to protect yourself — and, in a “horrible” world, there may come moments when you have to choose between protecting yourself or others. It is a poor reflection on us that, in those first critical seconds where one has to make a decision, only an elderly Holocaust survivor, Professor Librescu, understood instinctively the obligation to act.

Point two: The cost of a “protected” society of eternal “children” is too high. Every December 6th, my own unmanned Dominion lowers its flags to half-mast and tries to saddle Canadian manhood in general with the blame for the “Montreal massacre,” the 14 female students of the Ecole Polytechnique murdered by Marc Lepine (born Gamil Gharbi, the son of an Algerian Muslim wife-beater, though you’d never know that from the press coverage). As I wrote up north a few years ago:

Yet the defining image of contemporary Canadian maleness is not M Lepine/Gharbi but the professors and the men in that classroom, who, ordered to leave by the lone gunman, meekly did so, and abandoned their female classmates to their fate — an act of abdication that would have been unthinkable in almost any other culture throughout human history. The “men” stood outside in the corridor and, even as they heard the first shots, they did nothing. And, when it was over and Gharbi walked out of the room and past them, they still did nothing. Whatever its other defects, Canadian manhood does not suffer from an excess of testosterone.

I have always believed America is different. Certainly on September 11th we understood. The only good news of the day came from the passengers who didn’t meekly follow the obsolescent 1970s hijack procedures but who used their wits and acted as free-born individuals. And a few months later as Richard Reid bent down and tried to light his shoe in that critical split-second even the French guys leapt up and pounded the bejasus out of him.

We do our children a disservice to raise them to entrust all to officialdom’s security blanket. Geraldo-like “protection” is a delusion: when something goes awry — whether on a September morning flight out of Logan or on a peaceful college campus — the state won’t be there to protect you. You’ll be the fellow on the scene who has to make the decision. As my distinguished compatriot Kathy Shaidle says:

When we say “we don’t know what we’d do under the same circumstances”, we make cowardice the default position.

I’d prefer to say that the default position is a terrible enervating passivity. Murderous misfit loners are mercifully rare. But this awful corrosive passivity is far more pervasive, and, unlike the psycho killer, is an existential threat to a functioning society.
You can say that again. Read the whole thing.

Labels: , ,

DiscerningTexan, 4/18/2007 07:58:00 PM | Permalink | |

The Futility of Anti-Gun Laws

Eugene Volokh--no stranger to the law--has a brief but brilliant rebuttal today to the arguments of a great many on the suddenly-hysterical-about-guns Left:
Exactly What "Stronger Controls" Would Those Be?

A New York Times editorial about the Virginia Tech mass murder states, "What is needed, urgently, is stronger controls over the lethal weapons that cause such wasteful carnage and such unbearable loss." My question, now that we have a little more information about the criminal (though I stress far from complete information): What stronger controls over weapons would likely have stopped him from committing the murders, or even led him to kill fewer people?

Note that I'm not asking what controls would have prohibited him from doing something. Murder law, and for that matter the gun control law that banned firearms from campus, already prohibited him from committing mass murder. That didn't seem to help. I'm curious what "stronger controls" would likely have stopped a would-be mass murderer from killing, or at least killing as many.

Anyone?

Let's face it, though: isn't the left always hysterical about something? The only question that need be asked of any Democrat on a daily basis is: which soap-opera is playing today?

Don't believe me? Try clicking here any day of the week. And prepare to be stunned as you read in amazement at what some of your fellow "citizens" (a term used only in the strictest legal sense) actually believe.

UPDATE: Bill O'Reilly scores a "bulls eye" on the opportunistic gun control hypocrites.

Labels: , , ,

DiscerningTexan, 4/18/2007 05:33:00 PM | Permalink | |
Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Last Wish?


Cartoon by Mike Lester (click to enlarge)

Labels: , ,

DiscerningTexan, 4/17/2007 09:26:00 PM | Permalink | |

UPDATED Out of the Agony, Memories of a Hero--and Signs of an Academic and Moral crisis in our Education system

UPDATE: my first take did not quite come out exactly the way I wanted, so I've made some revisions for readibility and understanding.

Glenn Reynolds is all over the VT tragedy from multiple angles, and he gets the hat/tip for finding this one too: at least one story of true heroism came out of yesterday's events. Go read it now, then come back and let's wrestle with some questions about that dark day I can't quite let go of...

Finished? Good, let's talk:

Obviously, the valor and sacrifice of Professor Librescu--a Holocaust survivor--is a great, heroic story of sacrifice. And one thing that popped out as slightly ironic is that the most notable heroic act we know about from yesterday was performed by an engineering professor of Israeli descent.

Allow me to explain what I mean: once upon a time not so many years ago (or so we are told by Hollywood), most of the Jews of Europe were led to their slaughter with little or no resistance, like sheep--victims who did not even resist when they could have. Hollywood especially portrays these lost souls as the archetypal "victims"--rather than historical ones (witness films like Schindler's List); still I doubt that the folks in the Warsaw Ghetto uprising or the prisoners who led successful revolts at the Sobribor and Treblinka death camps would completely agree with this post-modern assessment of the unwillingness of Europe's Jews to fight back. So now, we fast forward to sixty plus years later: we are told that American college kids--the same age as those fighting for us abroad--are killed, allowing one shooter to systematically shoot them (and reload)--one by one, execution style-- while meanwhile it is an elderly Jewish professor who fights back. Is it only me who finds this juxtaposition ironic?

Obviously Professor Librescu deserves great honor and accolades for his bravery under fire. And those kids certainly do not deserve our derision in this awful moment--their loss is a tragedy beyond words. So I really want to take care not to be insensitive here--what I have to say is not about them except in a theoretical sense, and I do not want to dishonor the dead; they don't deserve it--still I just can't help myself from asking why didn't more of them try to fight back? It has been a burning question in my mind--and having not been in that terrible room that answer will never be known. But nevertheless I cannot help but wonder, what if some of them had?

In any case it is clear now that this one professor, anyway, did chose another path to frozen, impotent surrender to madness. He made the decision not to go gently into that good night--and sacrificed his life for his students, knowing full well it might come to that. And lives were saved because of him. That, my friends, is honor. That is taking responsibility for one's own life and the lives of others, rather than handing over his fate to a psychopath. And what that is not--Ladies and Gentlemen--is the act of a "victim". Then or now.

But what of the students who either could not or did not fight back? What can explain this? Is it the case now that gradually, American generations in their protective bubbles have slowly but surely been taught to un-learn these concepts which made the counrty great in favor of concepts like: it's all relative; one man's terrorist is just a misunderstood freeedom fighter; that America, what it stands for, and everything we have here--is the result of imperialistic plunder; that our country is NOT worth fighting for; that America is the primary source of of evil, as opposed to being the last line of defense against it? We have taught our young people to believe we are the cause of monsters wanting to extinguish us in the name of their God?? That we are all "guilty" because of our country's success, and thus somehow deserve punishment? I would be remiss if I did not point out that this same guilt goes a long way towards explaining how easily people have been swayed by a false Global Warming "consensus".

I think it is high time to ask whether the incessant "pacifism"--which our Leftist teacher unions are indoctrinating our kids' to believe from birth--is a "good" thing. Is it? What about responsibility? What about the notion that there is something greater and more noble and more worthy than the almighty and all-powerful self.

And what of the false idol of "self esteem"--which comes very often at the cost of dumbing down reward and achievement to a least common denominator, just so the non-achieving kids don't "feel bad". As an example, my neice ran in a cross country meet and got a Medal for finishing in the top 15. I ran track, and to me a medal for 15th is not something that encourages excellence--it encourages and condones mediocrity. It demeans the accomplishment of those who work hard enough and excel enough to finish in the top 3. While this self-esteem-uber-alles mindset may work in the short term in preventing "hurt feelings", in the long term it teaches our kids that not "hurting feelings" is a more important and worthy goal than is succeeding--and that failure is not a bad thing either.

This is not to discount the value of decency. But the result serves to squelch the competitive drive--which is the one advantage which has kept America as the leader of the world when it comes to can-do innovation. And making sure we all "feel good" definitely does not teach the inherent value of the individual, and teach kids to scratch and claw and fight to achieve for themselves. And so, how we then expect these kids to compete in a cutthroat global economy?

Character comes from taking your lumps and getting back up again. Lather, rinse, repeat cycle multiple times. And every time you stagger again back to your feet after having been knocked down, you do not give up; you know to your core that you can DO this thing--with enough patience, persistence, and effort. It is "The Little Engine that Could." Today's Academia would have written a book that would have been titled something like "The Victimized Oppressed-Group Member who Cannot be Expected To--so give them Your job". We now seem to treat failure as a result equally as "worthy" as achievement, and teachers teach that the American Dream is an "illusion". This is unconscionable to me. But it clearly is the end result of a society that values the RESULT of "equality" for all (the least common denominator) over giving each individual an equal opportunity to succeeed--but teaching that individual that doing so is their responsibility. In other words: we no longer teach our children about the real world. But I digress from my original point...

As I said, the purpose of this is not to criticize any of those unfortunate kids who did not fight back in Blacksburg--they were after all only reflecting the fatally flawed mindset of their 60's-generation teachers: "All you need is Love", "Everything is relative", "Imagine there's no countries...", "ALL people are good at heart"... etc. But clearly we live in times (and yesterday was a stark example) when this paradigm is completely inadequate to equip someone to handle a life or death situation without freezing into terrified submission or surrender. As I mentioned earlier, Forensic psychologist Dr. Helen Smith addressed this phenomenon yesterday, and it definitely is worth a click (if you haven't gone there already).

So part of the tragedy of 4/16/07 is that many of those kids in Blacksburg may not have had the emotional or ideological wherewithal to resist in that situation, because they simply did not have the world view or strength of character that would have come from a strong belief in self, duty, country. But I do not blame these innocent kids for this: I blame a broken Leftist "seniority over competence" educational system which has helped to transform scores of our kids into pacifist, relativist automatons. Again, I wasn't there and we will never really know for sure exactly how it happened. But the very sound of reports of the "execution style" killings really disturb me.

What is the solution? Well how about starting by insisting our educators teach our children things that we were taught which our kids are not being taught: about the greatness and goodness of their country and the rightness of the American dream and of our form of government; about Adam Smith, and Capitalism being the foundation upon which all successful societies are built--and that in this competitive age Capitalism is not a dirty word, but rather the greatest force for good for the planet; about the Founders, and the brilliant and heroic pioneers who made what we have possible; about the blood which has been shed by so many hundreds of thousands before them--just so that their lives could be so comfortable and easy today; about honor, and duty, and sacrifice for your fellow man; about doing whatever is necessary to protect the innocent and to keep this magnificent experiment we have going strong; about the kinds of things those frightened adults on Flight 93 did spontaneously--and also under no illusions--and which other brave American men and women do every day in far away places like Anbar province and Afghanistan and Sudan and Baghdad.

In the end, the seeming contrast yesterday of students allowing their own murder without resistance--weighed against the heroic deeds of an Israeli-immigrant Professor--appears to make some disturbing suggestions of how far we have fallen in our teaching our children the values and character they will desparately need for a self-sufficient and noble adult life; and it speaks to the drastic shift in priorities needed in our educational system to get us there.

As Tom Petty so aptly put it: "It's wake up time..." Let's get started.

Labels: , , , ,

DiscerningTexan, 4/17/2007 04:36:00 PM | Permalink | |

UPDATED AND BUMPED - Did PC Kill Kids at Virginia Tech?

UPDATE: Welcome Instapundit readers, and many thanks to Glenn for the link.

A new day to reflect on this tragedy brings excellent new links:

First of all, do not miss noted Ethicist Dennis Prager discussing the shootings on yesterday's radio show--he focuses like a laser beam on where the true morality lies in the issue of guns vs. self-protection.
Obviously, The New York Times is not listening. Who knew?

Stubborn Facts has self-defense tips. And Dr. Helen Smith asks a forbidden question: "Is Psychological Impotence in the Face of Violent Crime Really the Answer?"


Finally, just a reminder today as we all continue to grieve: although some Europeans may not see it that way, America is still the "last best hope of man on Earth." Don't ever lose sight of that.

**************** Original Post ********************
The blogosphere is teeming with chatter about the Virginia Tech tragedy today, but probably one of the best places for coverage and constant updates out here is
Pajamas Media.

Glenn Reynolds points out that it needn't have been this bad:

... reader John Lucas, who works with a Virginia law firm, emails that Va. Tech is a "gun-free zone." Well, for those who follow the law. There was an effort to change that but it failed: "A bill that would have given college students and employees the right to carry handguns on campus died with nary a shot being fired in the General Assembly." That's unfortunate. Had the bill passed, things might have turned out differently, though we'll never know now.
Here is a highly relevant quote from the above-linked Roanoake story about the defeat of the carry bill which would have allowed students to defend themselves:

The bill was proposed by Del. Todd Gilbert, R-Shenandoah County, on behalf of the Virginia Citizens Defense League. Gilbert was unavailable Monday and spokesman Gary Frink would not comment on the bill's defeat other than to say the issue was dead for this General Assembly session.

Virginia Tech spokesman Larry Hincker was happy to hear the bill was defeated. "I'm sure the university community is appreciative of the General Assembly's actions because this will help parents, students, faculty and visitors feel safe on our campus."

Uh, right...it's all about how they feel, after all. Guns are banned on the VT campus (as opposed to the anywhere else in the state of Virginia, where law abiding citizens who pass a background check can obtain a carry license and protect themselves), but I guess the shooter didn't get the message about not being allowed to have a weapon on campus... Go figure. What an enormous mistake, and what a horrific tragedy for those kids and those families.

If you think I am barking up a tree suggesting some students would have packed, just see what a VT student said in August 2006, after an on-campus shooting incident then. And keep in mind there is a large ROTC contingent at VT:

On Aug. 21 at about 9:20 a.m., my graduate-level class was evacuated from the Squires Student Center. We were interrupted in class and not informed of anything other than the following words: "You need to get out of the building." Upon exiting the classroom, we were met at the doors leading outside by two armor-clad policemen with fully automatic weapons, plus their side arms. Once outside, there were several more officers with either fully automatic rifles and pump shotguns, and policemen running down the street, pistols drawn.

It was at this time that I realized that I had no viable means of protecting myself. Please realize that I am licensed to carry a concealed handgun in the commonwealth of Virginia, and do so on a regular basis. However, because I am a Virginia Tech student, I am prohibited from carrying at school because of Virginia Tech's student policy, which makes possession of a handgun an expellable offense, but not a prosecutable crime.

I had entrusted my safety, and the safety of others to the police. In light of this, there are a few things I wish to point out.

First, I never want to have my safety fully in the hands of anyone else, including the police.

Second, I considered bringing my gun with me to campus, but did not due to the obvious risk of losing my graduate career, which is ridiculous because had I been shot and killed, there would have been no graduate career for me anyway.

Third, and most important, I am trained and able to carry a concealed handgun almost anywhere in Virginia and other states that have reciprocity with Virginia, but cannot carry where I spend more time than anywhere else because, somehow, I become a threat to others when I cross from the town of Blacksburg onto Virginia Tech's campus.

Of all of the emotions and thoughts that were running through my head that morning, the most overwhelming one was of helplessness. That feeling of helplessness has been difficult to reconcile because I knew I would have been safer with a proper means to defend myself.

I would also like to point out that when I mentioned to a professor that I would feel safer with my gun, this is what she said to me, "I would feel safer if you had your gun."

The policy that forbids students who are legally licensed to carry in Virginia needs to be changed. I am qualified and capable of carrying a concealed handgun and urge you to work with me to allow my most basic right of self-defense, and eliminate my entrusting my safety and the safety of my classmates to the government. This incident makes it clear that it is time that Virginia Tech and the commonwealth of Virginia let me take responsibility for my safety.
That was written on August 31, 2006. What if that young man had been in that building today--with his weapon? As Andrew's Dad posts here:
Just imagine if students were armed. We no longer need to imagine what will happen when they are not armed.
Virginia Tech has now reaped the whirlwind for its Utopian, PC, kum-bah-yah decision; yet another sign of just how compromised by leftist ideology Academia has become.

But I take no pleasure in saying this--actually I am ANGRY because of it: at least 32 innocent young people are now dead, a nation is shocked and all those families will have to live with the pain that never goes away; that of losing a child. Yet one question demands an answer: how many of those kids are dead because of a belief in Peace, Love, and Political Correctness? How many of those bodies are in the morgue tonight because bleeding-heart Academics would not allow students--who wanted to--to protect themselves? And how many more will have to die before people wake up to the fact that in the real world there are people out there who should not be. They may be two doors down from you or in the next car lane at the stop light. But they are there and they would think nothing of snuffing you out like a candle. And if you happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, how many of you would want the means to defend yourself or a loved one from imminent bodily harm from such a person?


Me, too. But make no mistake; the anti-gun zealots will try and turn this into a crusade for their cause, as they do every time something like this happens (will Michael Moore create "Bowling for Blacksburg"?...). Don't let them succeed.

I will close this long post with a quote from Roger Kimball at The New Criterion:
Of the many things that can be said about the horrible shooting at Virginia Tech today, one thing that we have already heard too often is that the shooting is offers a compelling argument against citizens owning guns. Right on cue, Jim Sollo, representing Virginians Against Handgun Violence, told reporters that "We live in a society where guns are pretty well accepted. There are 200 million guns in this society and obviously some in the wrong hands." Well, yes. And that means? That we should concentrate all instruments of violence in the hands of an increasingly bureaucratic and meddlesome state, thus rendering ordinary citizens even more defenseless? I don't think so, but that is what well meaning people like Mr. Sollo, appropriately horrified by such slaughter as we have seen today, conclude. My own feeling is that if a few responsible students and faculty had been in possession of the requisite firearms they might have made the death toll a lot lower, or even--had been especially alert--eliminated it altogether, or at least reduced it to the gratifying number of one, that of the perpetrator. A famous Roman military historian noted that si vis pacem, para bellum: if you want peace, prepare for war. Good advice, that. And if you want domestic tranquility, an armed and responsible citizenry ready and able to protect life and property is not a bad way to start.

Labels: ,

DiscerningTexan, 4/17/2007 02:00:00 PM | Permalink | |